11.23.201616 min read

Instagram Stories vs. Snapchat Stories: Which is best for small businesses?

When it comes to digital marketing, every business just wants to be heard. Social media platforms keep rolling out features that are helping brands cut through the noise and stand out. Yet, there are so many platforms to choose from that it can be hard for small businesses to decide where to invest their time.

One thing is for sure, video storytelling is here to stay and brands are working to figure out how they will adopt. Since the introduction of Instagram stories back in August 2016, many are questioning which “story”—Instagram or Snapchat—is a better investment. Especially now that Instagram just released live video and direct messages….the two platforms are even more similar than before. Take a look.

Instagram and Snapchat stories both:

  • Capture video and photos
  • Last for 24 hours
  • Can be recorded in 10-second increments
  • Have the ability to send and receive disappearing photos and videos
  • Can swipe left to rewatch a story
  • Have the ability to add text, drawings, and emojis to photos
  • Allow viewers to send messages via stories

With so many similarities, loyal users of each platform are confused and torn between where to devote their time. Should they share video to both? Cut one out completely or give in to the hype?

For a small business owner, simply put, “You ain’t got time for that”. It’s time to focus on where your customers are and where you should invest your valuable time. So let’s break this down to help you figure out which “story” is right for your business. Let the battle of Instagram Stories vs Snapchat Stories begin!

Audience and demographics

The first thing you should consider when choosing a social media platform is whether or not your target audience lives there. The size and type of audiences vary from platform to platform, but as a small business owner you want to go to where your people are.

Instagram logo.png
 

Instagram

Chances are, most small businesses are already dedicating their time to posting on Instagram, making it easier to utilize the audience they’ve already built. Instagram stories can be viewed by your followers, as well as anyone else who comes across your profile and in search.

This means you have the opportunity to reach an even greater audience. What sets Instagram apart is its large user base, it counts over 300 million daily active users, which is almost double that of Snapchat. And 90 percent of those users are under the age of 35, making it a solid choice for brands focused on the 18- to 34-year-old age bracket.

Snapchat logo.png 

Snapchat

Many marketers recognize that Snapchat is extremely popular with young social media users. In fact, seven out of 10 Snapchat users are millennials. Brands hoping to reach a younger demographic would best invest their time there. But as with all social media, the platform is ever-changing and still growing. In fact, now 50 percent of new Snapchat users are over the age of 25 allowing the opportunity to reach a wider age range. Users on Snapchat tend to be very loyal and extremely engaged which we’ll discuss below, keep reading.

Think about the audience you currently have, the one you want to acquire and then go straight to the source. Ask your customers if they’re using Instagram or Snapchat and where they prefer to consume your content!

Marketing your business

Although both Instagram and Snapchat stories are now extremely similar, they still have a few differentiating features that may help to promote your business in a unique way.

Instagram

Talk about a platform that loves marketers! With the roll out of Instagram business accounts and now the addition of stories, the user journey is flawless. Everything is in one place, your audience basically never has to leave the app!

Think about it like this; before, you could only say so much with a single post, but now, you can share a photo of your product to your Instagram feed, tell users to continue to the story for live demo or coupon code, and if viewers are interested, they can jump directly back to your profile, click on the link in your bio or the contact button (if you have a business account).

Sound impressive? It gets even better. Instagram just introduced the ability to insert links in your stories, so now users don’t have to rely on the solo link in your profile. In order to do this, your account must be verified, but this creates the ultimate CTA! You can also tag other users in your stories to help cross promote.

Instagram story link.png  Instagram story at mention.png

Source: Instagram

Talk about the ultimate customer journey! It’s just a matter of time before Instagram incorporates advertising into their stories, allowing you to manage your Facebook and Instagram ads all in one place!  

Snapchat

The biggest differentiator here is those dang filters everyone is crazy about (queue puppy face filter). But unless you yourself are the product of your business, chances are you won’t be needing a flower crown filter any time soon. However, there are other useful features that can enhance your videos like a time or temperature stamp, changing the playback speed, or adding emojis all of which allow for more creativity. 

The biggest feature, however, for small businesses, is the ability to create custom geofilters that can feature your logo. Use it yourself to promote an offer, event, or brand to your followers or catch random users that are in the vicinity of your business (can you say brand awareness?) Plus, Snapchat has already started dabbling in the advertising space. So, although they haven’t pushed brands to grow large followings, like Instagram has, they’ve provided other creative tools to reach users with.

Content type

Both platforms allow you to utilize a mixture of photos, videos, and drawings to tell an evolving story, but do users have different expectations for each?

Instagram

Now you have the opportunity to share more than you were able to with a single photo. You have a chance to show off the personality of your business, give a behind the scenes tour, provide demos, how-tos, or even recipes! And, now that Instagram has introduced live video, you can share even more as it’s happening in the moment! Plus, rumor has it, it might help you break through Instagram’s new algorithm.

Instagram story drawing and link.png Instagram story live video.jpg

Source: Instagram

With the addition of stories, you can continue telling the story beyond the photos on your feed. It may be difficult finding a balance between Instagram posts and stories, but if you do, it can be pretty powerful and effective (recall the customer journey above). But because of the public nature of Instagram stories, many users are questioning if they have to be “Instagram ready” in their stories. With Instagram feeds becoming so aesthetically pleasing, will users expect well-manicured stories too? In the case that they do, there’s an option to add photos from your camera roll which will help share high-quality images if you’d like.

Fortunately, Snapchat has paved the way for what a “story” looks like…more authentic and casual if you will, and many businesses are already using Instagram stories in a similar way. In fact, Snapchat users will often just save their Snapchat stories and share them to Instagram which gives them the best of both worlds (we’ll share how to do this at the end).

Snapchat

Getting users to follow you on this platform requires you to bring them from somewhere else such as your website, Facebook page, newsletter, or even Instagram. So there is a pressure to make sure the content you’re sharing in other places is engaging your following. If it is, those users will follow you to Snapchat, as well. The additional features on this platform allow you to share geofilters, time stamps, temperature, and speed, which can assist you in telling your story. 

Snapchat location stamp.jpg  Snapchat story time stamp.png Snapchat story temperature stamp.jpg

Source: @garyvee

As this article quoted, “Instagram is a follower platform where Snapchat is more of a best friend platform.” The followers on Snapchat are invested and interested in your business. This naturally can create a feeling of exclusivity. You can use this Snapchat stories to share upcoming product releases, promote meetups, or even give out monthly coupon codes knowing that your most loyal customers are most likely following you.  

User engagement

Both Instagram and Snapchat allows users who are watching a story to directly message the brand. But the big question is, what’s the likelihood your audience is actually watching your videos?

Instagram

The biggest advantage that Instagram stories have over Snapchat is that there are already millions of users on the platform. Over 60 percent of users log in daily, making it the second most engaged network after Facebook. But with that being said, will the app be too clogged? It’s convenient to have everything in one place, especially since viewers can click directly to your profile while watching a story. But if your audience isn’t already engaging with your content, they could miss your story.

Instagram stories are featured at the stop of a user’s feed. The order is not chronological but instead based on engagement. The ones that are furthest left (and first to be seen) are accounts that users interact with or view most often. If you find that your number of views isn’t increasing, or you’re already seeing a dip in engagement on your feed post as a result of Instagram’s algorithm change, then maybe you should direct your audience to Snapchat.

Snapchat

As mentioned before, Snapchat users tend to be more invested in your story because they had to physically add you, meaning they already had an interest. The process to follow someone requires a few more steps than just clicking the follow button on Instagram, which is why most Snapchat feeds are tailored to what the user is engaged in. Not to mention, the platform is focused around consuming stories with the average active user spending 25 to 30 minutes on the app every day.

There is also an argument that these users have a higher sense of urgency because the platform doesn’t provide any direct links and such. For instance, if you share a promo code, this audience may be more likely to jump off the app and go to your site before they forget the code because there is no “link in the bio” or additional post to reference.

Growth

When it comes to social media, the most common challenge is cutting through the noise and finding the chance to be discovered. If nobody ever sees what you share on social, how will they start following you? The journey to account discovery varies from platform to platform.

Instagram

There is a discovery page built into the app that features accounts a user hasn’t followed yet. This collection is based on an algorithm and selects photos based on a user’s interests, current followers, location, etc. Instagram stories have recently joined the discovery page, giving yet another opportunity get more eyes on your story and grow your following.

If your Instagram account is public, your stories are too. Anyone who visits your profile will be able to view your story. This means that you have two chances to earn a follower, through the content on your Instagram feed and also through the content in your Instagram story! It’s no surprise that big brands, like Nike, are already seeing more views on Instagram than on Snapchat.

Snapchat

Building a following on Snapchat can be difficult. We’ve already discussed that helping brands grow a following isn’t really what Snapchat is all about, and that is very apparent in the app. There is no discovery feature, no suggested followers, and when adding a username, it doesn’t even auto-populate potential matches. Snapchat users have to know your exact username or snapcode to begin following you and your story.

Growing a following on Snapchat involves promoting it via your other channels. Featuring your Snapchat name on your website, adding it to a newsletter, or asking your Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram followers to go add you on Snapchat. Then depending on how engaged this audience already is, they will either listen or they won’t. If you find that they aren’t listening, it may make more sense to invest time into Instagram, at least until Snapchat creates a discovery feature.   

Best of both worlds

Finding yourself still confused or unsure? Or are you a best of both worlds type of person? Or maybe you’re thinking, “show me the data”, and want to test both out. Well good news, there is an easy way to use both without double the work.

Simply start by using Snapchat, save each post to “my memories”, save them to your camera roll, and then upload them through Instagram stories. Bam! Same story on each platform. This way you can compare the numbers of views you’re getting, the growth of your following, ease of use, audience engagement, and see what’s worth your time.

Remember, you can save some time and go straight to the source. Ask your audience where they want to see you! Social media is all about trial and error. As we like to say, “nobody dies in marketing,” so don’t be afraid to get out there and test what works for your business! Remember to go follow Infusionsoft on Instagram and tell us what you think!

100 Ways To Make Social Easier.png

Zz04OTczY2RkYzdlYjNhNTc3ZjgxNDgzYTcyNGE2OGZkMg==.jpg

Karolina Bakanovas is well versed in all areas of social media and currently manages the social strategy for Infusionsoft. Her passion for discovery and writing led her to a create her own lifestyle blog, Sunkissedway.com. Originally from the beautiful state of Utah, she traded in her snowboard for sunny skies and palm trees. When she’s not busy blogging, she’s off being a “cool” cat lady, running half marathons, and soaking up the sun.

Was this post helpful?
Created with Sketch.
Infusionsoft cornerstone spinner
close button
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter!

5 Reasons to Subscribe:

1. Weekly tips to dominate sales and marketing

At our core, we're focused on helping you become a sales and marketing machine. We tap into the genius of the best salesfolks and marketers out there to give you daily tips to grow your leads, make more sales, and keep more customers.

2. Expert small business resources that cost you zero dollars

Want to go deep? We have you covered with free guides, webinars, and tools on a range of topics from marketing automation, CRM, and digital marketing to building sales and marketing strategies from the ground up. All for free. All for you.

3. We're focused 100 percent on small business success

We exist for one reason: helping small businesses succeed. We give you the ideas and insights you need to blow the competition out of the water. We serve business owners who are hungry to put in the hard work to grow their business and own the market.

4. We do the work for you

Running a small business is a 110 percent endeavor. You don't have time to surf Internet for the best small business insights and ideas out there. We'll do that for you with the best original content from our team and from industry experts and small business owners.

5. But wait, there's more!

Small business success means more than just sales and marketing, so we also hit on a range of topics to help your small business thrive, including personal and business growth, customer service, and business management.

6. Righteous GIFs

OK, we said five reasons, but we like to overdeliver...and GIFs. We really like GIFs. You're bound to see some righteous ones.

GIF of Ferris Bueler principal's assistant

P.S. We'll never give out your information. We'll only use it to send you awesome content and resources, if you're cool with that.